Student Solution

-->

"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world”
– Nelson Mandela

1 University

1 Course

1 Subject

Week6 DQ Applied Ethics

Week6

Q Week 6 – Discussion As we've discussed this week, throughout the history of capital punishment, a variety of methods have been used to carry out executions. The gas chamber, firing squads, and hanging have all been used in the United States and continue to be used in other countries. In 2000, lethal injection or "medicalized execution" became the standard method of execution in the United States. Although it is argued that lethal injection is more humane than earlier methods of execution, the use of medical knowledge to kill people has created conflict among medical professionals and penal officials. Executions involving lethal injection generally require the presence of a physician. • Should physicians participate in executions, or does this require them to go against their professional code of ethics - specifically, the principle of nonmaleficence or "do no harm"? • If not physicians, who should perform executions? • Or does the principle of nonmaleficence forbid anyone from executing another person? • How do human rights and societal rights factor into this issue? Support your answers using any of the ethical theories or concepts we have discussed thus far including but not limited to virtue ethics, utilitarianism, deontology, social contract theory, and so on.

View Related Questions

Solution Preview

The questions put forward this week are yet again full of ethical dilemma. It is very difficult to give straight answers to question like this. On a primary level medicalized execution is still killing of person and from that viewpoint it is going against the professional code of ethics of the physicians. The oath taken by physicians clearly say that they must do no harm. But taking the life of others is harming. The dilemma here is the classic collision between law and ethics. There are four basic rules that dictate the medical ethics. They are -respect for human beings, attitude of beneficence, nonmaleficence and justice.